P.O. Box 753
There has been a stunning
development in the half-century-old mystery of what happened to a Truax
Air Force Base F-89 Scorpion jet airplane that disappeared over Lake
Superior on Nov. 23, 1953.
The plane and its Madison-based crew - pilot Felix Moncla and radar
observer Robert Wilson - were never found. The F-89 had been dispatched
to track a large unidentified flying object that radar had spotted near
the U.S.-Canadian border, and the plane's disappearance has been fodder
for extraterrestrial theorists ever since.
It now appears the missing plane has been located.
Earlier this month, divers and engineers from the Great Lakes Dive Co.
posted on their Web site sonar photographs of what the group calls "the
legendary missing F-89 Scorpion."
Gord Heath, a Canadian UFO investigator who has devoted considerable
time to researching the F-89 disappearance - including several visits
to Madison, most recently this past July - called the new find "a huge
development" when we spoke Monday.
At the time of its disappearance in 1953, the F-89 was based not in
Madison but rather at the Kinross Air Force Base in Michigan. A Capital
Times story at the time explained that the plane and its crew "were
part of a Truax Field contingent stationed temporarily at Kinross Air
Base to substitute for Kinross personnel engaged in gunnery maneuvers
at Yuma, Ariz."
In an incredible and tragic coincidence, the F-89 Scorpion temporarily
stationed at Kinross was only one of two Truax F-89s to encounter
serious difficulty on Nov. 23, 1953.
Shortly after noon that day, another F-89 Scorpion, this one at Truax
with Lt. John Schmidt and Capt. Glenn Collins aboard, took off to test
the afterburners of newly installed engines. While the test seemingly
went fine, when the plane headed back toward Truax, witnesses below
reported hearing an explosion, and then the jet crashed into a marsh in
the Arboretum, killing both Schmidt and Collins.
It was less than six hours later that radar operators at Kinross, on
Michigan's Upper Peninsula, spotted the UFO in restricted air space
over the Soo Locks.
Moncla and Wilson went up in an F-89 Scorpion to track the unidentified
craft. Back at Kinross, radar tracked their plane closing in on the UFO
over Lake Superior. Moncla's last words from the cockpit were, "I'm
going in for another look."
The Capital Times reported what happened next: "The Truax jet was
followed on the radar screen at Kinross until its image merged with
that of the plane it was checking - then it was lost."
That odd radar image - of the mystery craft seeming to swallow the
Truax jet, then both disappearing from the screen - has fueled the
extraterrestrial theories. U.S. officials claimed the rogue blip on the
screen was an off-course Canadian airliner, but Canadian authorities
have denied that any of their planes were in the area.
In his 1955 book, "The Flying Saucer Conspiracy," Donald Keyhoe wrote:
"The mystery craft and the F-89 came together far off-shore, about 100
miles from Sault Sainte Marie. ... As quickly as possible, search
planes with flares were roaring over Lake Superior. After a fruitless
night search, boats joined the hunt as American and Canadian flyers
crisscrossed a hundred-mile area. But no trace was ever found of the
missing men, the F-89 - or the unknown machine."
But then, in October 1968, the Sault Daily Star newspaper carried a
story headlined, "Do aircraft parts belong to missing F-89?" Two
prospectors had found the parts, including a tail section, on the
eastern shore of Lake Superior. The paper quoted Air Force sources
saying the parts belonged to "a high performance military jet aircraft."
Years later, when Gord Heath, the UFO investigator I spoke with Monday,
tried to get records from the Canadian government of the jet parts
found in 1968, he was told no records existed.
Heath has spent much of the past five years trying to learn the fate of
the missing Truax F-89. He has a Web site - www.ufobc.ca/kinross -
devoted to it. He has made research trips to Madison and has a section
on the city on his site. A documentary film crew from Canadian
television accompanied Heath on his last trip here in July.
Now, suddenly, the Great Lakes Dive Co. find has considerably upped the
ante on this 53-year-old mystery. You can learn more about the company,
and view the sonar photos of the F-89, on its Web site,
www.greatlakesdive.com.
According to Adam Jimenez, spokeman for the company, the group formed
in 2001 out of "a yearning to explain some of the enduring mysteries of
the Great Lakes." Late in 2005, members were searching for two sunken
French minesweepers when circumstances led them to the area over which
the F-89 had disappeared. Five days into their sonar search, the site
notes, "the computer returned some amazing images." It is, they seem
certain, the Truax F-89.
Incredibly, sonar has also discovered an "unknown" near the sunken jet.
Jimenez describes the unknown as, "The object that the F-89 collided
with is metallic and plowed into the lake bed in a similar manner as
the F-89 south of the aircraft wreckage. The object bears a strike mark
that matches a hole where the port side wing of the F-89 used to be
(this supports the collision theory). We are a little baffled by the
actual physics of the crash though...if you can imagine a plane
colliding with another object and a wing shearing away, it seems as
though the plane would spin out of control and disintegrate on the
surface of the lake. Also, the plane is in deep water, yet appears to
be plowed into the lake bed, how could the plane (or object for that
matter) maintain enough power to accomplish this. I'm telling you this
because we don't have all of the answers to this mystery yet. Our best
guess is that the collision took place at or near sea level at
relatively low speed. This scenario would preserve most of the aircraft
structure, but still doesn't account for the plowing. We do have side
scans of the object, and are currently discussing the possibility of
releasing them."
There has been a lot of discussion within the team about the mystery
object... but without ROV footage, it is very hard to determine what
exactly it is. It is not a part of the F-89, and does not appear to be
a part off of another aircraft...it is simply a mysterious object.
But like all great quests this one has hit a snag.
"2006 began as an ambitious project season for us, we were looking
forward to further work at the F-89 site", said Jimenez . He added,
"Then we received some bad news. The Canadian government refused to
allow us to use our ROV at the wreck site without first providing them
the GPS coordinates of the site and allows either a Coast Guard escort
or government official to accompany the expedition. We were stuck, we
don't want to give up the site (especially because of the object, and
it's potentially huge significance) but we need stay on the good side
of the Canadians."
"So as it stands now, we have just issued a letter to the Canadian
government essentially abandoning work on the F-89 site this season",
sums up Jimenez.
They next plan to take underwater video of the plane, which seems in
remarkably good condition in perhaps 500 feet of water. Heath, who has
been in contact with the Great Lakes Dive Co., says its condition -
part of the tail is missing - matches up with the parts that were
purportedly found in 1968.
Heath does not believe that the discovery means there wasn't an
extraterrestrial ship involved in the 1953 disappearance. What if they
were after the crew and not the plane? The sonar photos indicate the
cockpit canopy of the F-89 is still intact. In time we should learn if
the bodies of Felix Moncla and Robert Wilson are inside. If they
aren't, it won't mean aliens got them - they might have bailed out -
but if they are, the extraterrestrial theory might be put to rest. Some
dead men can tell tales.
Source: The Capital Times
http://www.madison.com/tct/news/index.php?ntid=96691&ntpid=6
Photo: The Great Lakes Dive Company - www.greatlakesdive.com
-
THE ENDURING MYSTERY DEPARTMENT -
UFOs - Explaining the
Unexplainable

Fund for UFO Research wants answers to lingering questions.
In the summer of 1952, the mayor of Alexandria was trying to clean up
the city’s “skid row” on lower King Street, Virginia farmers were
suffering through a punishing drought, the United States Senate was
investigating a communist plot to infiltrate the Boy Scouts. But over
the nighttime skies of the Washington area, something far more dramatic
was happening.
“Until unidentified objects — we call them targets — began moving onto
our radar scopes, I thought people who reported flying saucers were
just seeing things,” said Air Force Radar Specialist James Ritchey at
the time. “Now, I don’t know what to think.”
Ritchey’s bewilderment — splashed across the front page of the July 29,
1952 edition of the Alexandria Gazette — was understandable.
Experiencing the unexplainable can be an existential threat for many
people. But for an Air Force guy whose job it was to identify objects
in the sky, being unable to recognize an airborne craft can be a tough
pill to swallow.
“I don’t think the objects were balloons or anything moving with the
wind because their speed was greater than that of the wind,” Ritchey
told a Gazette reporter. “I don’t see how they could have been ducks,
geese or any kind of night birds — these can be picked up on radar, but
they wouldn’t explain the lights. As I said, I just don’t have an
explanation, and neither does anyone else as far as I know.”
Over the next few weeks, several explanations emerged in the pages of
the Gazette. Winthrop Coxe and Rollin Gillespie — two writers with the
International News Service — theorized that the unexplainable
phenomenon had been “swarms of electrical particles” whirling through
the air at high speeds. In a column that appeared on the editorial
page, they attempted to put a scientific face on debunking the
widespread notion that Washington was being visited by
extraterrestrials.
“In the laboratory, any studious schoolboy can wind a wire around an
iron bar, send through the wire a current of electricity and produce a
magnetic field,” Coxe and Gillespie wrote. “They are real, but there is
nothing to fear from them.”
Their explanations didn’t wash for many skeptics, and Washington’s
famous 1952 experience with UFOs became a local legend. To this day,
events from that summer have yet to be fully explained. And for many
who research UFOs, this is only one story among thousands — disparate
pieces of a mystery that has yet to be solved.
For many years after World War II, UFOs gripped the American
imagination. The phenomenon began in the summer of 1947, when a
west-coast pilot named Kenneth Arnold reported seeing nine disk-like
objects flying over Mount Rainier, Wash. He said they were traveling at
tremendous speeds, which he estimated to be at least 1,200 miles per
hour. The next month, mysterious debris was found at a crash site near
Roswell, N.M. The subsequent newspaper coverage opened a floodgate,
with reports of UFO sightings becoming commonplace.
“Right after the war, people started seeing things that nobody could
identify,” said Don Berliner, chairman of the Alexandria-based Fund for
UFO Research. “The press doesn’t cover these things anymore, so it
appears that nothing is going on. But we have just as many UFO
sightings now than we did back then. It’s just that people are afraid
of being laughed at.”
Berliner doesn’t want people to laugh. He’d rather that they think —
and maybe apply a little science. The fund that he helped create in
1979 has been doing this for more than 25 years: providing grants to
clinical psychologists, publishing scientific articles, sponsoring
conferences, hosting seminars and holding press conferences. From his
apartment on the second floor of Hunting Point, Berliner oversees the
operation of the fund.
“I want proof,” said Berlinier. “Scientists say that there could be
millions of other civilizations. Are they interested in travel? We
don’t know?”
Half the money comes from the sale of publications like “UFO Sightings
in the New Millennium” by Richard Hall or “Final Report on the
Psychological Testing of UFO Abductees” by Ted Bloecher. The other half
of the fund’s money comes from donations from private individuals. The
group’s executive committee meets when needed to make decisions about
how and when to invest.
“Unfortunately, we don’t make that many decisions because we don’t have
that much money,” said Rob Swiatek, a member of the executive
committee. “Things pick up when there is more interest in the subject,
like in 1997 when it was the 50th anniversary of the 1947 sightings.”
Swiatek, a physics patent examiner with the United States Patent Trade
Office, said that he would like to see more mainstream scientists and
academics working on the subject. He said that would lend some credence
to the topics, which is often overlooked or scorned. The mystery of
unexplained events is a lingering source of interest for Swiatek and
many devotees, who see the UFO phenomenon as a series of unanswered
questions.
“I am convinced that something is going on that is not prosaic or
mundane,” Swiatek said. “We’re having encounters with non-human
intelligence.”
Critics of UFOs say that it’s all a hoax, or that weather patterns are
responsible. Yet those who claim to have seen them swear by their
presence. After the Washington flap in the summer of 1952, the Air
Force was at great pains to explain itself. So it initiated Project
Bluebook, a 17-year investigation of the UFO sightings culminating in a
controversial report by nuclear physicist Edward Condon. Titled
“Scientific Study of Unidentified Flying Objects,” the document was
popularly known as the “Condon Report.”
“Our general conclusion is that nothing has come from the study of UFOs
in the past 21 years that has added to scientific knowledge,” the 1968
report said. “We feel that the reason that there has been very little
scientific study of the subject is that those scientists who are most
directly concerned, astronomers, atmospheric physicists, chemists, and
psychologists, having had ample opportunity to look into the matter,
have individually decided that UFO phenomena do not offer a fruitful
field in which to look for major scientific discoveries.”
Essentially, Condon’s committee of scientists reported, there was
nothing to it. But many critics of the Air Force investigation said
that the unexplained events in the body of the text were not considered
in the sweeping denial at the conclusion of the report. At the time the
report was issued, Don Berliner was working for a group known as the
National Investigations Committee On Aerial Phenomena — a private group
that acted as a central clearinghouse for reports of UFO sightings,
making television appearances and conducting radio interviews from its
Dupont Circle office.
“We established ourselves as a reliable source of information in a
field where there’s not a lot of reliable information,” Berliner said.
“I had never worked so many hours in my life. I was supposed to be a
staff writer and sighting analyst, but I did everything except sweep
the floors.”
In the late 1960s, the National Investigations Committee On Aerial
Phenomena was expanding its membership dramatically, and the
involvement of prominence scientists gave the organization academic
credibility. But after the 1968 Condon Report, mainstream scientists
abandoned the cause in droves. The Air Force shut down its
investigation, and reports of UFO sightings became the topic of
ridicule and scorn.
“Even today, the vast majority of people who see UFOs keep quiet about
it,” Berliner said. “They are afraid of being laughed at.”
But reports of sightings persist, and questions linger. That’s why
Berliner and others continue to investigate the subject, asking
questions they say remain unanswered. Berliner has written a number of
books on UFOs, published countless articles and remains one of the
country’s preeminent experts on the topic. For him, the Holy Grail of
UFO research would be for his organization to get its hand on a piece
from the 1947 crash landing at Roswell.
“Somebody out there had to have taken a piece when nobody was looking,”
Berliner said. “We’ve got pages of protocol for what we want checked.”
A native of Columbus, Ohio, Berliner graduated from Bexley High School
in 1947. He studied journalism and accounting at Ohio State University
before joining the Air National Guard to help pay for college. One day,
he read a newspaper account in the Ohio State Journal of a UFO story
that was being investigated by a Ground Observer Corps headquartered
across the street from his father’s accounting office.
“So I threw around some military language and BS’d my way in,” Berliner
said. “I had no more business there than my Aunt Sophie. But they
didn’t know that.”
Berliner said that he then passed along a series of reports to
newspaper reporters covering the subject in the local press that
documented regional UFO sightings of aluminum-colored discs zooming
through the air at tremendous speeds. The chance encounter was an early
experience with UFO sightings, and Berliner later left the Air National
Guard and took a job as a reporter for the Painesville Telegraph.
“The city editor found out that I had an interest in UFOs,” Berliner
said. “So I got calls from all the people who said they had seen UFOs.
Most of the calls were nothing, but one sighting was a real mystery.”
He wrote a story about that sighting in 1961 and sent one copy to the
Air Force and another copy to the National Investigations Committee On
Aerial Phenomena. The Air Force initially claimed it was a rocket
launch at Wallops Island, Va. That didn’t seem to make sense to
Berliner, who wrote a letter disputing the ability to see such a launch
from Ohio. An Air Force officer wrote again to change the explanation
to a scientific research balloon launched in Iowa that was 600 miles
away from the eyewitnesses who reported the sighting. He wasn’t
satisfied with that explanation either.
“The government was playing fast and loose with the truth,” Berliner
said. “If I hadn’t challenged their initial explanation, it would have
gone into the record book that way.”
In 1962, Berliner packed up and headed for Washington, D.C. He wanted
to be at the center of things, and he knew that the nation’s capital
would offer him the kind of research opportunities he wanted to pursue
a writing career. He took a series of jobs writing newsletters for
various Washington associations like the National Aeronautics
Association, which was then engaged in a massive effort to put a man on
the moon. But his interest in UFOs persisted, and he eventually joined
the National Investigations Committee On Aerial Phenomena as a staff
writer and sighting analyst.
“We were at the center of the world,” Berliner said. “Every week, we
would get calls from airline pilots who had seen things. This convinced
me even more that were was something going on.”
But the Condon Report abruptly ended public fascination with UFOs in
1968, and Berliner left the organization to launch a freelance writing
career that includes a wide range of subjects: aviation, space travel
and, of course, UFOs. He moved to Hunting Point in 1969, and has lived
in the same second-story apartment ever since. By the late 1970s, the
National Investigations Committee On Aerial Phenomena had all but
vanished — and many people skeptical of the official explanation were
eager to continue its work.
“The press wasn’t covering it anymore,” Berliner said. “So it appeared
that nothing was going on. But it was.”
By 1979, Berliner and others decided to take matters into their own
hands. They created the Fund for UFO Research as a way to funnel
resources toward investigating the unexplained UFO sightings as well as
alleged alien abduction stories.
“Some of my best friends are abductees,” Berliner said. “Their stories
are consistent in ways even they don’t recognize.”
One of the Fund of UFO Research’s major undertakings involved giving a
grant to a clinical psychologist who looked for similarities in the
psychological makeup of people who claim to have been abducted by
aliens. The study was unable to find any — evidence to Berliner and
others that there is more to their stories than delusion.
“People all over the world are having highly consistent experiences,”
Berliner said. “There’s got to be something to it.”
With public interest in the topic of UFOs at an all-time low, the
subject receives little attention outside of late-night cable
television. The Fund for UFO Research continues to conduct seminars on
UFO-related topics and host conferences where abductees can get
together and share their stories. But the group continues to have a
hard time attracting scientists and academics.
“Scientists flee in terror when you bring up the subject,” Berliner
said. “Probably 90 percent of the people who see things don’t’ want to
report them. And those 10 percent who do have no idea who to call.”
But Berliner’s group carries on — with every phone call to the group’s
voice mail and every hit its web site. For many people, the mystery of
the unidentified flying objects continues to be obscured by unknown
facts and missing pieces to the puzzle.
“I’ve been at this for 40 years, and I still don’t know what the
blasted things are,” Berliner said, staring out the window into the
middle distance of the sky over the Woodrow Wilson Bridge. “A lot of
people want to know. I want to know.”
Source: The Connection Newspapers
http://www.connectionnewspapers.com/article.asp?article=70393&paper=59&cat=104