ComicBookNetworkEmag Archives Index | RSS
<< June26, 2004 - [ComicBooknet E-Mag] CBEM 478.07 June26, 2004 - [ComicBooknet E-Mag] CBEM 478.09 >>

Subject: [ComicBooknet E-Mag] CBEM 478.08 - June26, 2004



------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
Yahoo! Domains - Claim yours for only $14.70
http://us.click.yahoo.com/Z1wmxD/DREIAA/yQLSAA/bGIolB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~->

CBEM 478 rolls on . . .
-------------------------------------------------------------------
[10] ComiX-Fan Reviews                              Eric J. Moreels
                                              X-Fan Editor-in-Chief
                                               x-fan@bigpond.net.au

From ComiX-Fan:
http://www.comixfan.com/xfan

NEW X-MEN: ACADEMY X #2
Reviewer: Kenneth J. Galati, ScribingSkye@yahoo.com
Quick Rating: Great!
Story Title: Assembly: Choosing Sides 2 of 6

Wearing the white and gold.

Written by: Nunzio Defilippis & Christina Weir
Penciled by: Randy Green
Inked by: Rick Ketcham
Colored by: Pete Pantazis, Soto and Chu
Lettered by: Dave Sharpe
Assistant Editors: Stephanie Moore & Cory Sedlmeier
Edited by: Mike Marts
Editor-in-Chief: Joe Quesada
Publisher: Dan Buckley

New X-Men: Academy X #2 picks up right after the events of the
first issue. The dialogue is very much real and in the moment for
these young kids trying to figure out if they get to remain as a
group or not. This issue is chock full of character development and
underlying plot points bursting to come forth in later issues.

New X-Men: Academy X #1 had us get reacquainted with Sophia
Mantega, Josh Foley, David Alleyne, Laurie Collins and Noriko
Ashida. We also got a tour of the facilities as well as a little not
so safe round in the danger room. Lastly we met with the new
headmaster and headmistress Scott Summers a.k.a. Cyclops and Emma
Frost respectively. The issue came to a dramatic conclusion when
David announced that Cyclops is about to break the student body up
into teams.

In this issue of New X-Men: Academy X we see the reactions the kids
have to David's announcement. It then quickly fades as Julian
Keller, the resident punk, gets mixed in with our little band of
mutants. I just love to not to like this character. I was also
pleased to see the return of Dani Moonstar as the mentor of these
kids. She seems more in control and confident then when she was in
the New Mutants brief run and I like it. Dani's always been a
favorite character of mine. She's a strong, independent and
intelligent young woman whose never been given that much spotlight.
It's about time that someone gave her the respect she deserves. Back
to the issue at hand we get a little secrecy on Dani's part about a
new recruit. Although all one needs to do is look at the cover to
guess who that is. We are also treated to the return of Sooraya
Qadir or better known to most as Dust from Grant Morrison's New
X-Men run. Until this issue, if my memory serves me well, we never
actually saw Sooraya's face. Sooraya and her roommate get acquainted
with each other and I'm already enjoying their interaction. The next
segment of the comic has Noriko having a chat with Headmaster
Cyclops and I must admit her closing line to him gave me a big
smile. The bulk of the issue has a Basketball game taken to a more
fun level and a cameo from everyone's favorite frosty hero. The
ending was great with the introduction to some of the squads most
specifically three; one of which is run by Emma Frost, another by
Cyclops (although we are not told who they are) and the squad run by
Dani. As the students were announced we get to see them in costume.
Which overall was enjoyable but a few of them have the same shoes
with gold straps (bands?) on them and I'm just not digging. Although
that's because I find it hard to wear anything gold period, but
overall the costumes are great. Dani's costume looks a little too
formal but it does have that teacher feel.

Randy Green's pencils are again wonderful and seemed even better
then issue one. He has nice details to the backgrounds giving a
realistic school yard vibe. Pete Pantazis, Soto and Chu's colors are
energetic and vibrant. The art team perfectly matches the fabulous
writing team of Nunzio Defilippis & Christina Weir who make me wish
I was going to this school especially because Julian Keller would
have had two or three black eyes by now. (Note: this reviewer is not
a violent person but boy that kid is just trouble.)

In closing New X-Men: Academy X #2 is such an enjoyable read for any
age group. It has a level of sophistication for adults (sort of like
me) and kids alike. It's about kids dealing with being away at
school. It has kids dealing with bullies. It has kids dealing with
strange powers with a world that fears what they are. It's all of
the above and without the need for big bad villains. It's school
and that my friend is villain enough. New X-Men: Academy X #2 is on
sale now. What are you waiting for; you finished reading my review
now go get your copy!

ART: 4.0
STORY: 4.0
OVERALL: 4.0

DISTRICT X #2
Reviewer: Erwin Rafael, erafael@globalpinoy.com
Quick Rating: Excellent!!! Read it!!!
Story Title: Mr. M Part 2 (of 6)

Now this is the reason why I bought this book...

Written by: David Hine
Cover by: Steve McNiven
Penciled by: David Yardin
Inked by: Alejandro "Boy" Sicat
Colored by: Avalon's Andy Troy
Lettered by: Richard Starkings and Comicraft's Rob Steen
Assistant Editors: Cory Sedlmeier and Stephanie Moore
Edited by: Mike Marts
Editor-in-Chief: Joe Quesada
Publisher: Dan Buckley

What a great development. After feeling that #1 was just fairly
standard, Hine and company totally won me over with this issue. The
X-Men Reload event has been quite retro so far, as the books try to
hearken back to the classic X-Men feel. District X, however, has
been progressive, building on the foundations of Morrison's run and
exploring uncharted territory. This issue, in particular, shows the
tremendous storytelling opportunities of having a mutant town in
the center of New York City.

Do not be carried away by the Marvel marketing hype that District X
is a solo series starring Bishop, because it is not. It's more akin
to Fables and Astro City in that it is more about a place and the
group of people that reside in it. There were about twenty
characters that were featured at one time or another in this issue,
and David Hine wonderfully presented these characters, no matter how
briefly, in a very fascinating light. It's a nice piece of "ensemble
acting", with each character adding color to the District X concept
while not hogging away the spotlight from the other characters. I
can't remember having fond memories of so many characters after
reading just 22 pages.

Hine's exploration of mutant powers as a random phenomenon and as a
"burden" for a lot of people is a very refreshing take. The classic
X-canon mostly portrays mutancy as problematic because of the
discrimination that comes with it. In this issue, there were no
bigots/racists/geneticists around, but Hine still effectively
showed how being a mutant can be a thorn in someone's life. SPOILERS
AHEAD! I can't help but feel sympathetic towards the plight of the
Falcone family, who has earned the ire of their neighbors for Mr.
Falcone's unflattering ability to birth rodents from his body. Then
there's Ms. Hamilton, whose webbed hands and feet has disqualified
her from becoming an internationally renowned swimmer. Who would
ever forget the disturbing scene of a mother getting addicted to the
"juice" secreted by her Toad-like son? But the ultimate
heart-wrencher came at the final scene, where we see Officer Ortega
denied of enjoying love because of her wife's unfortunate condition.
I am a sucker for a well-written drama, and this is drama at its
finest. David Hine's superb script has a lot of heart.

Hine, however, did not just hit the low-notes. He celebrated
mutancy as well, making for an interesting contrast that showed that
mutant powers may be a boon, or at the very least, may not be a
hindrance to one's success. SPOILERS AHEAD! Take for instance the
case of Hanna Levy, whose mutation has not hampered her from
becoming a successful social scientist. Or how about Mr. M, who
makes himself useful to the neighbors for his amazing ability
to..ehem...fix toasters. One of my favorite scenes was Mrs.
Falcone's fond remembrance of her husband's mutation during their
wedding day. These light moments which peppered the story made me
feel more for the unfortunate plight of the characters.

Hine's writing, though, did not just rely on excellent
characterization. He used excellent technique as well. I was
wondering at first why Hine used a lot of mid-page scene
transitions until I realized that there was a very smooth flow from
one scene to another. This may seem to be a trivial element, but the
transitions gave a sense of interconnectedness among the different
characters. Each of them may be preoccupied with his/her own
situation, but Hine tells us that they're all playing an important
role in a bigger drama.

Like most of you, I thought that the "Mr. M" title referred to
Bishop, who has this infamous M-shaped tattoo over his right eye.
Apparently, I was mistaken, as Hine introduced a different Mr. M
this issue. I'm really curious as to what role Mr. M would play in
this series. He hasn't done much, but interestingly, he has this
uncanny point-of-view from his apartment wherein he gets to see
almost all of the characters involved in the story. I'm really
interested to see what Hine has in store for Mr. M and why he gets
top billing in this story-arc.

David Yardin and Alejandro Sicat delivered on the art side of
things with their impressive storytelling. Their realistic and
laid-back art style exuded a grounded atmosphere which fits the
story and shows how mutation can be a very ordinary thing for the
people residing in this side of Manhattan. However, what stands out
for me was the art's ability to convey emotions. SPOILERS AHEAD!
Whether it be Mrs. Falcone's sad smile as she remembers her wedding
day, or the disturbing image of a mother on a high while licking
Toad juice, the emotions attached to the scene could be seen in the
artwork alone. I particularly would never forget the image of
SPOILERS AHEAD! Ortega despairing over his frustrating situation
with his wife. That final page was very powerful.

Again, while I do not have any problems with the interior art, it's
the cover art that irks me. While McNiven's art is a thing of
beauty, it just sends off the wrong message about what the book is
all about. This book is not about Bishop. This book is not
action-oriented (so far). I am all for iconic covers as long as they
don't mislead the reader. I hope there would be better covers for
this title in the future.

There has been a growing buzz about District X from fans and
reviewers alike, and the book certainly deserves it. This is the
best thing to come out of the X-Men Reload event, and I hope you
won't pass the opportunity to enjoy a great book. Pick it up and
read it!!!

ART: 4.5
STORY: 4.5
OVERALL: 4.5

ULTIMATE X-MEN #47
Reviewer: Daniel M. McNea, d_mcnea@hotmail.com
Quick Rating: Good
Story Title: The Tempest: Part 2

"hmm, six more you say?"

Written by: Brian K. Vaughan
Penciled and Inked by: Brandon Peterson
Colors by: Justin Ponsor
Letters by: Chris Eliopoulos
Assistant Editor: Nick Lowe
Editor: Ralph Macchio
Editor In Chief: Joe Quesada
Publisher: Dan Buckley
A special thanks to: C.B. Cebulski

It would seem that many people who comment in the review threads do
so simply based on the ratings system as opposed to actually
reading the review and taking in every aspect and view point
beforehand. So with that in mind, I immediately direct those people
who felt I judged last issue too harshly to the ratings below. You
may now set your worries at ease.

Ultimate X-Men #47 picks up immediately after the cliffhanger last
issue, revealing the fate of Jean-Paul Beaubier. The stuttering
Sinister (yes, that's right) has arrived to thin out the mutant
population and Jean-Paul was number five on his hit list. The first
four murdered are seen in one brief glimpse. The mostly
recognizable victims, all teens, warrant an initial twinge of
sympathy for the loss but that passes once you soon realize "Hey,
better them than the X-Men eh?" Don't take comfort with any false
sense of security though, Sinister is apparently contracted by an
even bigger bad to take down TEN mutants. You do the math.

While the police half-heartedly investigate the case, Wolverine
does his own silent snooping at the scene. Unfortunately, even he
comes up empty-handed. This prompts the senior members of the team
to hit the streets after a very reluctant Xavier agrees to letting
his "children" get involved.

As I previously stated, I wanted to wait until the new creative duo
settled in before sealing the final verdict and it looks as though
they are both finding the comfort zone. We could have a fun,
involving murder mystery with this mutant massacre and it is a safe
bet that Vaughan relishes in stressing out fans in wondering which
little Indian is next to go. Personally, I hope his disdain for the
616 version of a particular character doesn't mark them for death
here.

The dialogue and story overall felt more enjoyable and real this
time around, though I am still not 100% certain he has everyone's
voice just yet. Professor's worrisome demeanor seems an about face
from last issues icy visage. Of course that could have also been
for Emma's benefit. Also, Peter's snap reaction to an inquiry on
his behalf felt like yet more ambiguous play from the boys at
Marvel. Vague it up a little more fellas? Was he flattered,
interested, appalled, what?! Enough tiptoeing around the topic of
his sexuality because you know fans have been wondering and after
three years it is no longer intriguing, it is annoying.

I am not sure of the reasoning, but Peterson's work seems more
relaxed and fluid this issue. While there are still inconsistencies
and I do wince at heavily crosshatched faces, the characters appear
overall softer and appealing. Some segments feel reminiscent of J.
Scott Campbell (which isn't a bad thing) but this issue is more
akin to the Brandon Peterson work I had fond memories of. I am
curious to know if the rounded ears of the infamously pointy-eared
Jean-Paul were a conscious decision or not. Justin Ponsor's colors
definitely make the scenes pop. They are alternately vibrant and
moody in the precise moments needed.

Ultimate X-Men was not a title in danger of my dropping and I am
overall thankful with the creative team, but as with any reviewer
who loves the medium he or she critiques, it frankly sucks to have
to review crap. If Ultimate X-Men accelerates along it's current
course, I will be there for some time to come and enjoying the
ride.

Besides, Dazzler's gotta comeback sometime!

ART: 3.5
STORY: 3.5
OVERALL: 4.0

EMMA FROST #12
Reviewer: Mitch Brown, mitchbrown@comixfan.cjb.net
Quick Rating: Above Average
Story Title: Mind Games, Part 6 of 6: Going Mental

You mean, Emma's got powers?!?

Writer: Karl Bollers
Penciler: Carlo Pagulayan
Inker: Dennis Crisostomo
Colorist: Pete Pantazis
Letterer: Virtual Calligraphy's Cory Petit
Cover Artist: Greg Horn
Assistant Editors: Cory Sedlmeier & Stephanie Moore
Editor: Mike Marts
Editor In Chief: Joe Quesada
Publisher: Dan Buckley

For the past six issues Emma Frost readers have been dragged
through an incredibly gruelling, agonizingly slow-paced storyline
that seems designed for no other reason than to sap every last cent
out of its audience's wallets. Mind Games, a six issue storyline
that--even being generous--could've been condensed down to four, is
finally, mercifully over.

So, was the conclusion actually worth the wait? Well, sort of.

Ever since she left Frost House, we've seen tiny pieces here and
there of Emma's abilities. The untrained and unsure Emma's attempts
at using her telepathy constructively have so far been less than
successful. This issue, Emma finally manages to turn that around
and get some use out of those great big telepathic muscles in her
cranium. Only problem is that now she seems to be using them
altogether too well, showing a level of control and creativity that
seems to have no basis in her actual experience. Turning her mental
powers against her kidnappers, one-by-one Emma delves into their
thoughts and fears, exploiting and manipulating them in an attempt
to undermine and ultimately defeat Lucian and his crew.

Its certainly welcome that Karl Bollers allowed Emma to remember
her abilities, but where did this sudden expertise come from? I
could be wrong but even with Xavier's tutelage it took much longer
for Jean Grey to gain such a level of control. Perhaps its
adrenaline or gut instinct, but the level of Emma's telepathic
prowess in this issue just seems totally inconsistent with what we
have seen so far. On the upside of this, the creativity and
manipulative talents that she displays this issue go a long way to
linking present day Emma Frost with the younger incarnation seen in
this series.

One of the problems that this series faces is that just about every
reader knows that by story arc's end, no matter the danger she
faces Emma will get away most unscathed. This being the case, I
found that I really didn't care about her predicament at all this
issue, and care even less about the fates of Lucian and his cronies.
The cover itself completely gives away a major plot development at
the end of this issue - not that we didn't all see this destination
in the pipeline anyway.

The unfortunate part about this issue is that Emma Frost #12 is
once again, actually quite a good individual read, accompanied by
some more-than-capable artwork, that has been marred by the
horrendous pacing of this story arc. Had the events of this issue
happened one or two issues ago, I would be cheering for Emma's
triumph. As it is though, the conclusion of this arc felt more like
finally getting to use the bathroom after an eight hour car drive,
the last hour and half being spent nursing an unthinkably full
bladder.

Take that how you will.

This will be my last issue reviewing Emma Frost, with a new
reviewer joining the fray with #13, who I hope can get more out of
this series than I have been of late.

ART: 3.0
STORY: 2.5
OVERALL: 3.0

WOLVERINE: THE END #4

Reviewer: Brian Wilkinson, bewilkinson@yahoo.ca
Quick Rating: Good
Story Title: The End: Part 4

Ah, so THAT'S why he's been talking to himself....

Written by: Paul Jenkins
Pencils by: Claudio Castellini
Colors by: Paul Mounts
Editor: Axel Alonso
Editor In Chief: Joe Quesada
Publisher: Dan Buckley

I want to glory and revel in this series as much as I did with
Origin which is both a fair statement and brutally cruel to the
creators at the same time. Origin, for all of its many shipping
flaws, broke a lot of new ground in a character many said was best
left in the shadows. My own fears were quickly set aside once Paul
Jenkins was announced as writer and disappeared completely once I
got into the story. It was just that good. Each issue coming out was
like Christmas.

Unfortunately, I don't feel that same happy glow with Wolverine:
The End. The writer remains at the top of his game and the art here
by Castellini is good, but somehow the magic that filled the first
outing just isn't here.

It could simply boil down to an asthetic appreciation. The
cardstock covers loving put together by Joe Quesada are gone, the
interiors by Andy Kubert and Richard Isanove are missing and rather
than a brilliant look at the world of tomorrow as Logan's demons
finally come calling, we get a dark tale that brilliantly explains a
lot of the mysteries of Origin but the artist execution is somewhat
lagging.

This may not be the fault of the artist as it seems more lacking
due to the colorist. Here entire panels are shades of the same color
with lots of murky backgrounds and effects that leave me wanting
more definition rather than less. Logan and his brother don't look
much alike and it's that minor attention to detail that bugs me
about this issue (then again, I don't look a thing like my brother
which is a good thing. Ugly bugger.)

The most credit for this book goes to Jenkins for taking a few left
turns as well as some obvious ones. John's connection to their
mother's scars was explained as many had guessed when Origin came
out, but the most shocking surprise was that Logan hasn't been
talking to himself at all (which is what Jenkin's purposely made it
look like) but rather an old and unexpected friend.

The main confusion from this issue comes from what John was asking
Logan to become. There are many things you can infer from the
conversation, but the motivations and past connections he alluded
to aren't explained properly enough. Certainly not enough for my
tastes given Logan's reaction at the end of the issue.

What makes me the most curious is that this tale seems to have come
to a close in a way. There are a hundred questions that readers
could still ask, but that's nothing new when it comes to this
character. How Jenkins handles these final issues will determine how
well it will stack up against all of his previous work. My
impression is that these issues are critically important both to
Jenkins career, Marvel's reputation, and to cement a lore for a
character that has become one of comicdoms most beloved characters.

ART: 3.0
STORY: 3.5
OVERALL: 3.0

X-MEN #158

Reviewer: Anthony Zisa, anthonyzisa@hotmail.com
Quick Rating: Good
Story Title: Day of the Atom, part 2 of 4: Immortals

"Day of the Atom" continues as the X-Men investigate the mysterious
mutant signature in China.

Writer: Chuck Austen
Penciller: Salvador Larroca
Inkers: Danny Miki
Colorist: UDON
Letterer: Virtual Calligraphy's Rus Wooton
Assistant Editors: Stephanie Moore & Cory Sedlmeier
Editor: Mike Marts
Editor in Chief: Joe Quesada
Publisher: Dan Buckley

Last month in X-Men, the Reload event mandated a certain amount of
exposition to be dumped on newer readers, in an effort to catch
them up on the happenings of what is really the least accessible
book to Marvel's idea of these "new" readers, those coming fresh to
the X-Men with perhaps only a movie knowledge of the franchise. That
being said, with four titles sharing the word "X-Men" in some
variation, and with three of those focusing on established
characters, there is going to be some degree of drain on the
characters that have become well-known thanks to the movies; even
the flagship Astonishing X-Men contains only two movie-characters,
so exposition is in order to dump all the necessary information onto
the reader at these periodic and editorially-mandated points. "Black
Holes," the first part of "Day of the Atom," was not necessarily the
most graceful way to get that information across, but with it out of
the way, writer Chuck Austen is free to position his book and
distinguish it from the other twenty-plus titles in the line, and
the two other books with the main X-characters.

To a large degree, he is quite successful with the positioning
aspect. "High adventure" and "soap opera" are X-Men buzzwords, but
Austen provides enough of both that it does not seem like lip
service. "Immortals" is a fun X-Men book in the traditional vein,
and while it is not really anything groundbreaking, it has enough
developments that it cannot be dismissed as servicing the trademark
over telling its story. "Day of the Atom" as a whole is shaping up
to be a traditional X-Men story, and Austen takes advantage of the
audience's favorite tropes in such a tale. As for setting itself
apart from the pack, the book is less successful, as the story
Austen seems to be telling is not particularly different in tone
from, say, "The End of History," currently running in Uncanny X-Men,
which is probably a minor issue for most. It is not doing anything
new, or startlingly different, but it does what it wants to do
well.

Picking up where last issue left off, the X-Men have discovered
"Xorn" at the heart of a major catastrophe in China. Naturally,
they remain wary, considering what happened last time a "Xorn" was
brought back to the mansion. Furthermore, this Xorn just destroyed
an entire city before his helmet was clamped back on, which stopped
his power from further warping the gravity around him and, as a side
effect, destroying larger areas of land and killing more people. The
sensible thing would seem to be leave Xorn here, and call for
backup, rather than bringing him to the mansion. Austen's script is
smart enough, however, to deal with this problem in a manner
(invoking dubious ideas of responsibility) that is just human enough
to empathize with, as bad a decision as it may be. Plot points such
as this one do not need explanation, but it is nice to see that
Austen thinks highly enough of his reader that they will spot the
flaw in logic and not be fully content.

Not that this decision to take in Xorn comes to fruition this
issue, as eight immortals sworn to protect the Chinese homeland do
not take kindly to the removal of the man who just destroyed a swath
of land of considerable size and who just killed a large number of
Chinese citizens, nor to the presence of a foreign superhero team in
their territory. As is par for the course in this sort of story,
they fight, and the X-Men are kicked around like novices. As a
conceit of the genre Austen is writing in, it works. There is no
explanation for who these characters are; they're a collection of
similar powers and traits to the respective X-Men they pair off
against. And, as such, the plot moves along briskly without worrying
too much of the inherent silliness of the whole affair; this is how
things are done in this sort of story, and Austen realizes that
overthinking the premise will just draw attention to the superhero
tropes he is utilizing. His script finds its voice somewhere between
smart and too smart for its own good.

Meanwhile, as the high adventure aspect occurs on the other side of
the world, the soap opera aspect takes root at home, as Jay Guthrie
and Sammy bond over Jay's recently lost love. "She Lies With
Angels" was one of Austen's less than stellar efforts, and bringing
the affair over into this story could backfire. The script,
however, utilizes "She Lies With Angels" to further advance Sammy's
character, rather than trying to wring more pathos out of Jay. It
has been hinted that Sammy is being fast-tracked to the main team
power-wise, so Austen balances it out by fast-tracking him to main
team personality-wise. Sammy is a quintessential X-character, good
at his heart, and the interaction between Jay and he is extremely
well-done. Nicely pacing the issue, Austen also uses the Jay/Sammy
sequences to foreshadow future events, as some presence stalks the
Xavier grounds.

Just as Xorn's return last issue was sure to spark controversy,
Austen further invites anger and recrimination by severely injuring
fan-favorite X-Man, Gambit. Gambit's injury makes sense, and is
borne out of a throwaway idea presented earlier in Reload.
Unfortunately, that idea was presented in a different book, and not
hinted at well- enough in Austen's setup issue. It is a minor issue,
because the injury works regardless, but it would have given it an
additional level of resonance is Austen, and not Claremont, had
implied Gambit was rushing back to combat-readiness despite not
being entirely sure his powers were ready. Either way, it should
provide some interesting drama in the next few issues, and Austen,
to his credit, shows the danger and sacrifice implicit in the
superhero life without resorting to a less reversible injury. It
will be interesting to see where Austen goes with this development,
and how it will affect the Gambit/Rogue relationship that has just
gotten back on track.

Obviously, whether or not one likes the script will likely hinge on
how they feel about Xorn's return and Gambit's injury. Being rather
ambivalent to both, I found this issue extremely entertaining plot-
wise. The dialogue, while not perfect (Iceman and Havok's tension
does not work all that well), has some extremely good moments
(Sammy and Jay's conversations). In addition, Juggernaut's
characterization continues to be enjoyable, providing a perfect foil
to a group of X- Men who have been doing the job for so long that
they may have become a little too sure of themselves. All in all, a
surprisingly strong story package in light of last issue's
less-than-stellar setup.

Salvador Larroca's art, however, continues the high quality of last
month. Austen's script, with more action, is perfectly suited to
Larroca's action-oriented style, though Larroca captures the slower
school scenes well. The storytelling is strong, though there is one
notable flaw in the art, relating to Gambit's injury. The way it is
drawn, it is not clear how only one part of his body was damaged;
whether this will be cleared up next issue is important, but as a
free-standing plot point, Larroca's rendering of this crucial scene
is problematic. A small flaw in an otherwise stellar effort, but a
small flaw at a major juncture in the plot that really disrupts the
flow when it is revealed what Gambit injured. A real shame, because
Larroca nails many of the other sequences, particularly those
between Sammy and Jay.

"Immortals" is a straight-up traditional X-Men story. It does not
aspire to be anything more, and it succeeds in what it wants to do,
entertain. Austen and Larroca display a nice understanding of how
traditional superheroics work in the context of a more modern
audience, and despite a few flaws throughout the book in both
script and art, deliver a pretty nice package this month. There is
real potential for "Day of the Atom" in light of the honestly
interesting, if controversial, plot developments of the storyline. A
clear shift in Marvel's thinking about how the X-books should
function, but a well-done example of what the franchise's return to
superheroics can be--smarter than expected, without overthinking the
concept.

ART: 3.5
STORY: 3.0
OVERALL: 3.5

CBEM 478 continues . . .



Thanks for subscribing to the Comic Book Network Electronic Magazine (CBEM)
--------------------------->Disclaimer<---------------------------
This is an ANNOUNCE only mailing list, only the Editor can send
messages to the list.  No one else has access to the subscriber list.
Replies to these messages will be received by the Editor ONLY,
so you must CC: individual contributors if you want them to get
your E-Mail.  The E-mail to the E-mag MAY be used in future issues at
the Editor's discretion UNLESS you specifically request that they not
be.  It is our policy to withhold names and/or Addresses, by request only,
from letters of comment.  All contributors are required to use their real
name and have a valid Email address for their columns to be published.
Send Email comments to: ComicBkNet@aol.com

Material for inclusion in the Emag - press releases, solicitations,
column submissions, Letters to the Editor, guesses for the trivia
contest should be sent to ComicBkNet@aol.com

The EDITOR, not the submitter, has final approval and edit rights on
ALL material.  Printed comic books and advanced copies for review
in the Emag should be sent via US Mail or UPS to

David L. LeBlanc
84 Heather Circle
Jefferson, MA 01522-1419

TO Subscribe send a message FROM the intended address to:
        ComicBookNetworkEmag-subscribe@yahoogroups.com

TO Unsubscribe send a message FROM the address to be dropped to:
        ComicBookNetworkEmag-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

You may also unsubscribe from the Egroups Web page at the short cut
below.
            Shortcut URL to the Egroup page:

        http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ComicBookNetworkEmag

All contents COPYRIGHT 2004 The Comic Book Network.
This messages may be reproduced only in its original form, and in its
entirety for non-commercial purposes.  Contact the original author(s)
or the Editor for permission to use individual items.


Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
     http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ComicBookNetworkEmag/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
     ComicBookNetworkEmag-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
     http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/











<< June26, 2004 - [ComicBooknet E-Mag] CBEM 478.07 June26, 2004 - [ComicBooknet E-Mag] CBEM 478.09 >>
ComicBookNetworkEmag Archives Index | RSS
Google
 
Web http://archives.zinester.com
Archives powered by Zinester's Mailing List Service
Details on ComicBookNetworkEmag
Browse for more newsletters at Zinester's Ezine Directory
Managed by Zinester's Mailing List Management