ComicBookNetworkEmag Archives Index | RSS
<< June17, 2006 - [ComicBookNetwork E-Mag] CBEM 579.4 June17, 2006 - [ComicBookNetwork E-Mag] CBEM 579.8 >>

Subject: [ComicBookNetwork E-Mag] CBEM 579.6 - June17, 2006



-----------------------------------------------------------------
COMICS OBSCURA                                        Mike Curtis
                                           shandafa@cyberback.com

[COMICS OBSCURA are facts Mike Curtis has dug out during his 30
years of collecting Superman and writing about comics. His
website for his comic imprint is www.shandafantasyarts.net ]

IT'S MORE THAN JUST TO HOLD UP HIS LITTLE GREEN TRUNKS

Burt Ward as ROBIN on the 1966 TV series BATMAN also brought a
little known innovation to the character's costume.  From his
original appearance in 1940, Robin has always been credited with
having a Utility Belt, same as Batman's but compartments were
never shown.  That included the two film versions in 1943 and
1949.  Ward's costume had "capsules" on his belt, while West
graduated to pockets.
_________________________________________________________________
-----------------------------------------------------------------
[6] One Superman Returns, But These Won't!            Mike Curtis
                                           shandafa@cyberback.com

[Mike contributes the COMICS OBSCURA for this publication, runs
his own publishing imprint SHANDA FANTASY ARTS, and is a long
time fan of all things SUPERMAN.]

As the time for SUPERMAN RETURNS to open in theaters gets closer,
Warner Brothers has announced plans to re-release scores of
Superman productions on DVD for the first time, including THE
ADVENTURES OF SUPERMAN, LOIS AND CLARK, THE NEW ADVENTURES OF
SUPERBOY as well as the two Kirk Alyn serials and the Richard
Donner cut of SUPERMAN II. However, there are a FEW Superman film
projects you WON'T be seeing on DVD this year, and we're going to
examine 5 of them.

-----------------------------------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------

IT'S A BIRD IT'S A PLANE IT'S SUPERMAN the 1975 TV Musical

------------------------------------------

Now before we begin, we should make it plain that the SUPERMAN
Broadway musical was not a terrible adaptation of the Man of
Steel.  On the contrary, it won a chapter in the book BEST PLAYS
0F 1965-1966 and that is where you can see around 30 photos from
the production.  It had stars (Jack Cassidy, Linda Lavin, and Bob
Holiday as Superman) a hit song (YOU'VE GOT POSSIBILITIES) and
was full of satire and production numbers.  It is still
occasionally performed around the country today, usually without
the flying scenes.  Months of work went into the production and
it had the bad luck to debut on Broadway at the Alvin cheater
just as BATMANIA hit the country. It was perceived as camp like
the Adam West series and closed after 200 plus performances. The
original soundtrack was re-released on DC in the 1990's and is a
great listen for fans of the theater and Superman.

In addition, Bob Holiday carried on George Reeves' tradition of
visiting children's hospital wards as Superman, and also has a
book out (SUPERMAN ON BROADWAY) about his experiences in the
uniform. His last public appearance was in Metropolis Illinois
(Home of Superman) some years back.

This production of IT'S A BIRD IT'S A PLANE IT'S SUPERMAN! is an
entirely different animal. Produced for the late night TV series
ABC'S WIDE WORLD OF ENTERTAINMENT, and airing at 10:30 central
time on a Friday night, it probably missed the kids who might
have viewed it.  But if they had seen it, they would have turned
it off, dismissing it as cheaper than Filmation's SHAZAM TV
series.

There's an article with a photo that ran in TV GUIDE the week of
the showing, but aside from that, no merchandise or material was
produced for the film.

The plot of the original musical follows Metropolis' hero
Superman, who is reviled by DAILY PLANET gossip columnist MAX
MENCKEN (played by Jack Cassidy). He also has an enemy in DR
ABNER SEDGWICK, who feels he has been looked over too many times
for the Nobel Prize and wants to take revenge by destroying the
"world's symbol of goodness, Superman".  To that end, he enlists
THE FLYING LINGS, a Chinese acrobatic team (no one will pay to
see them fly when they can see Superman fly for free.)  They
arrange for Superman to be occupied when a building is destroyed,
and then Sedgwick and Mencken team up to finish off the Man of
Steel, who is also demoralized by Lois's defection to another
man.  At last the Lings reveal themselves as agents of Red China
and offer Sedgwick a Peace Prize, while Lois is kidnapped.
Superman rallies, beats the Lings, Sedgwick falls into an atomic
pile and Max apologizes.  The end.

For television, the producers decided to "improve" it and you
know that spells T-R-O-U-B-L-E with a capital T that stands for
...well anyway, the TV production is several levels below the
stage version.  First, Nixon has gone to China, so the Lings are
out.  We now have gangsters with big hats and pinstripes and a
new musical number.  They don't even rate names like the Lings
had, but are billed as "Gangster" and "Boss."  Jack Cassidy has
passed away and Kenneth Mars cannot begin to try to fill his
place, but he tries.  David Wayne becomes the only actor to
oppose both Batman (THE MAD HATTER, 1966) and Superman on film as
he plays Sedgwick.

Linda Lavin played Sydney (who?), secretary to Mencken who has a
jones for Clark and gets to sing YOU'VE GOT POSSIBILITIES, the
hit song.  Here Loretta Swit shows why she rarely acted outside
of MASH in the role. .   Leslie Ann Warren is a very forgettable
Lois Lane.  Perry White barely had a part in the original
production, but game show host Allen Ludden outshines the rest of
the cast here. And he's not even an actor!

And Superman himself?  That's DAVID WILSON.  Looking up his bio,
he seems to be one of those actors who has had lots of parts but
never broken out.  He resembles Patrick Duffy of DALLAS in the
part, and went on to play in a DALLAS THE EARLY YEARS telefilm.

So how else did they improve it?  Well, it's supposed to be campy
(so they thought) so let's have cartoon background and sets, with
color separation dots. And they made jokes in the 1950's about
cardboard sets and props on CAPTAIN VIDEO, but by golly these
sets and props are literally made of cardboard!   And hey, we
gotta have commercials, so let's have cliffhangers like the old
serials or soap operas.  And just to make it all nice, we'll get
GARY OWENS of LAUGH IN to do the narration.

----------------

Feh.

--------------

I wasted an evening back in 1975 watching this bomb, and have
seen about ten minutes of it since I got it on tape.

Possibly the lowest point comes when Wilson as Superman has to
show he can't go on.  In the original, Holiday sang a moving
song.  Wilson ties an anchor to his neck to throw in the river.

The ONLY (and I emphasize that) GOOD improvement is a brief scene
when Stuart Getz and Michael Lembeck play "Jerry and Joe"; two
teenagers who want to write and draw stories about Superman.
Remember, this was before the general public knew about Siegel
and Shuster.

----------------


SUPERMAN THE MUSICAL (as it is sometimes known) is commercially
available, but if you decide to view it, you'd better get some of
those chains Superman likes to burst across his chest so you
don't get up and turn off the TV after the first few minutes.
Hide the remote too. Get some of those eyelid openers like in
CLOCKWORK ORANGE as well. You'll be a Batman fan in no time!

Read more about it here: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0339210/

Next week, we have our final article in this series (then you can
cleanse your palate by going to see SUPERMAN RETURNS.)  It's the
strangest Superman film of all, and maybe the least seen, since
it has never shown in a theater or on Television.  But it has a
mad scientist, an electric ray, art by CURT SWAN and it's a LIVE
ACTION version of the first Fleischer cartoon!  Join us next week
for THE CASE OF THE COSMIC COMIC starring RALPH RUTA JR.!
_________________________________________________________________
-----------------------------------------------------------------
COMICS OBSCURA                                        Mike Curtis
                                           shandafa@cyberback.com

[COMICS OBSCURA are facts Mike Curtis has dug out during his 30
years of collecting Superman and writing about comics. His
website for his comic imprint is www.shandafantasyarts.net ]

I ALWAYS LIKE TO HANG AROUND OTHER FOLKS IN TIGHTS

Besides doing the voice of BATMAN in SUPER FRIENDS, and NEW
ADVENTURES OF BATMAN, ADAM WEST also played the live action hero
in the 1966 TV series and movie...plus another odd project.
Hanna Barbera filmed two hour long specials, CHALLENGE OF THE
SUPER HEROES and a celebrity roast using many of the DC stars.
West and his Robin BURT WARD joined RIDDLER star FRANK GORSHIN in
these two comedy outings.  Batman got to interact live on camera
with his JUSTICE LEAGUE friends FLASH, GREEN LANTERN, HAWKMAN,
BLACK CANARY, THE ATOM, HUNTRESS and CAPTAIN MARVEL. Villains led
by the Riddler included SINESTRO, SOLOMON GRUNDY, MORDRU, GIGANTA
and DR. SIVANA.
_________________________________________________________________
-----------------------------------------------------------------
[7] Suspended Animation                Michael Vance & Mark Allen
                                      MiklVance2@worldnet.att.net
                                      http://www.starland.com/sus

[Michael Vance, a professional writer since 1977 and has been
published in dozens of magazines including Starlog and Jack and
Jill, and as a syndicated columnist and cartoonist in over 500
newspapers. His history book, Forbidden Adventure: The History of
the American Comics Group, has been called a "benchmark in comics
history". He ghosted an internationally syndicated comic strip,
and his wrote own strip, Holiday Out, that was reprinted as a
comic book. Vance also wrote the comic books Straw Men, Angel of
Death, The Adventures of Captain Nemo, and Bloodtide. He is
listed in the Who's Who of American Comic Books and Comic Book
Superstars. His short stories have appeared in dozens of
magazines and recorded by actor William (Murder She Wrote)
Windom. Suspended Animation, has been published for more than
sixteen years, and Vance worked in newspapers for 22 years as an
editor, writer and advertising manager.

Mark Allen lives in Western Oklahoma with his wife and daughter.
He has been a Baptist minister for over 15 years, and has also
written for the Oklahoma news industry. Having indulged in comics
for nearly 30 years, Mark now enjoys using the written word to
share with others what he believes is a true, and extremely
under-acknowledged, art form.]

Graphic Classics: Rafael Sabatini/ 141 pgs. & $11.95 from Eureka
Productions/various artists and writers/sold at comics shops and
www.graphicclassics.com

Once a celebrated author, Rafael Sabatini is virtually unknown
today. Even his tales of the pirate Captain Blood, 'immortalized'
in motion pictures by actor Errol Flynn, are slipping into
obscurity. If nothing else, Sabatini is proof positive that fame
is fleeting.

The 13th volume in the Graphic Classics series of literature
adapted into comics is proof that it shouldn't be fleeting.
Sabatini wrote high adventure, supernatural, and other genres
tales in novels, short stories, and poetry. They are deserving of
praise.

My favorite art in this collection is by Gerry Alanguilan. The
best story is every story; Sabatini was talented, and these terse
adaptations of his work are entertaining and worth your
attention.

The entire Graphic Classics series is strongly recommended.

MV

Superman Family #173 [1975]/50 pgs. DC Comics/various artists and
writers/sold at comics shops and on-line auctions.

They were different.

In general, comic books predating the 1980s were story rather
than character driven, and were created for an audience of young
readers around the age of ten. Indeed, Superman Family almost
seems silly compared to today's character driven, hard-edged, and
even grim titles.

Reading an issue for the first time in thirty years was
refreshing.

"Superman's pal" Jimmy Olsen, Supergirl, Lois Lane and Superdog
are the featured cast. Inside, Jimmy becomes a superhero,
Supergirl marries the man who destroyed her home planet, Suberdog
saves Superboy, and Lois Lane becomes a series of super-bugs. No
one is killed, no one is a drug addict, and life doesn't stink.
No kidding.

Couldn't we get a few optimistic titles back on today's market?
Pretty please!

Oklahoma Cartoonists Collection (OCC) Hall of Fame member E.
Nelson Bridwell and OCC Associate Kurt Schaffenberger produced
the Lois Lane "Super Bug" story. Recommended.

MV

Order you copy of the all-Vance horror paperback Apocris 1 at
http://www.lighthousemediaone.co.uk/FutureProjects.html

Interested in the exciting Oklahoma Cartoonists Collection and
Toy and Action Figure Museum? Go to
fourcolorcommentary.blogspot.com/
_________________________________________________________________
-----------------------------------------------------------------
COMICS OBSCURA                                        Mike Curtis
                                           shandafa@cyberback.com

[COMICS OBSCURA are facts Mike Curtis has dug out during his 30
years of collecting Superman and writing about comics. His
website for his comic imprint is www.shandafantasyarts.net ]

IT WAS OLD HAT TO HIM

Batman star ADAM WEST was no unknown to television before the hit
1966 TV series.  He was a regular on THE DETECTIVES with Robert
Taylor, and co-starred with a monkey on the local Hawaiian kid
series THE KINI POPO SHOW.
_________________________________________________________________
-----------------------------------------------------------------
[8] ComiX-Fan Reviews                             Eric J. Moreels
                                             x-fan@bigpond.net.au
                                     http://www.comixfan.com/xfan


[Editor's note: Some of the following reviews have spoilers to
plot details. This is a TEXT ONLY newsletter so those spoilers
are not hidden by HTML code as they are on the ComiX-fan site.]

X-MEN: THE END - MEN & X-MEN #6
Reviewer: Brian Wilkinson, bewilkinson@yahoo.ca
Story Title: X-Men: The End - Men & X-Men

The end, a beginning, and a lot in between.

Writer: Chris Claremont
Artist: Sean Chen
Cover Artist: Gene Ha
Inker: Sandu Florea
Colorist: Avalon's Ian Hannin
Letterer: Dave Sharpe
Assistant Editors: Andy Schmidt & Stephanie Moore
Editor: Tom Breevort
Editor In Chief: Joe Quesada
Published by: Marvel Comics

Maybe it's just me, but I've felt a growing dissatisfaction with
some of Marvel's titles in the past few years with shining
beacons being produced by Joss Whedon on Astonishing X-Men, Mark
Millar on The Ultimates 2, Brian Bendis on Ultimate Spider-Man
and Peter David on X-Factor.

That's part of what made me so enthusiastic for Chris Claremont's
epic. I loved Sean Chen's work on Wolverine, and while I feel his
talents are better suited to focus on a solo character, I thought
this was a good pairing for what would be a balls-out story
letting Claremont do what he does best.

As huge a Claremont supporter as I am, I must admit that I found
the final results a little disappointing. Maybe it was the huge
Marvel marketing machine lumping it in with the then-hot property
Lord of the Rings, but somehow between the start and the finish
we got a story, that while 18-issues long, still managed to feel
rushed at the end.

I started buying comics years ago and it was Claremont's X-Men #1
that got me hooked into more than a decade of reading and loving
the mutant characters in the Marvel Universe. That love lead me
here, to Comixfan, and even to doing a bit of writing for Marvel
itself. For all of these things and more, I'm grateful to the
talent that Chris Claremont clearly has. If I wanted more from
him it's because I want to use up every bit of talent and energy
he has left just to appease me and take my breath away.

Claremont excels in some of his regular work is his
characterization and humanization of characters that are easily
shoved into spandex and into big fights. Claremont mistakes drama
for action in this series and instead of delivering an emotional
and heartfelt story that sums up his own achievements it descends
a little into Hollywood action movie clich‚ with an epilogue that
is only a couple of pages long.

The final battle is fairly well done even if some of the
specifics of it seem a little vague to me. I take it Phoenix came
back (again) and brought a whole bunch of other people back to
life to somehow contain/calm down Cassandra Nova and then they
disappeared into space. So... were they dead already, brought
back, and then died again? I'm not sure how or why Wolverine and
Kitty were brought out into the battle at the very end there
either.

The image, the tree of life, was wonderfully done and even if the
specifics elude me, the symbolism of what Claremont was trying to
achieve came through. The story that he presented wraps things up
nicely and gives a brief hint of what this future has in store
for the characters. The action was nicely done and the art was
some of the best it has been in this title.

Claremont lived up to a lot of the hype dumped on him and
included a massive roster of characters. It's a shame that this
series was based on events of two years ago (Colossus was still
dead when this series started coming out, hence 'Kid Colossus'),
but taken as an epilogue to that era, it's a well-told story.

The negatives here are that it's dated (unfortunately) and
Claremont missed the mark by not having more of an emotional
impact. More interaction between Magneto and Xavier was needed to
bring it to more of a cathartic place for readers as well as the
characters.

The positives are that it's a great epic and a wonderful place to
leave off. If I were considering leaving comics (which I have
thought of on more than one occasion), then this might be the
sort of thing that I would use as a jumping off point.

More positives: lots of death, lots of action, and lots of
potential for future 'The End' universe stories should Claremont
wish to continue exploring it.

This series will make for a great trade collection and is key for
any Claremont collection, but ultimately it falls just a tiny bit
short for me of being a true must-have classic. Still worth the
read, but not necessary in order to get the full flavor of the X-
Men mythos, particularly in light of some of Claremont's other
comic achievements.

OVERALL: 3.0

CABLE/DEADPOOL #29
Reviewer: Alan Bergin, alan_bergin@yahoo.com
Story Title: The Domino Principle ~ Part 2; The Politics of Fear

Because she doesn't trust me. She can't.
She thinks I'm going to ruin this -
Like I have everything else for as long as she's known me

Writer: Fabian Nicieza
Pencillers: Ron Lim
Cover: Mark Brooks
Inker: Pat Davidson
Colorist: Gotham
Letters: VC's Cory Petit
Editor: Nicole Boose
Consulting Editors: Barber & Macchio
Editor-In-Chief: Joe Quesada
Publisher: Dan Buckley
Published by: Marvel Comics

Now this, this was good. Great even. Fabian Nicieza has always
shown a good deal of kindness to the characters that he has
either created or taken under his wing. The inclusion of players
such as Commcast, Prestor John & Citizen V in his current Cable &
Deadpool run, suggests that even though they have been and
perhaps once again will be consigned to Marvel's waste-paper
basket, there's still enough in the tank for them to have some
degree of influence in the C&DP universe. Similarly, Nicieza's X-
Force run has been fondly remembered for the subtle level of
characterization that he had given to the erstwhile New Mutants,
as they trudged through the big hair, big shoulderpads & big
booms that marked the X-Fiction of the early 90's. Cable,
Cannonball, Rictor & Siryn all got their start in a run that
marked them out as characters who are (at long last) beginning to
matter in the X-Men mythos. While Domino may never have had the
mass appeal of her fellow X-ladies, her participation in this
particular arc has been both pleasurable & satisfying. Her final
actions in the last few pages once again demonstrate the
importance that Nicieza attaches to the performance of his cast
in his elaborate set-pieces.

You could assume that this issue would kick-off with the the
social & political upheavel that had been generated in the
aftermath of Flag-smasher's assassination, but you'd be wrong. As
revealed at the close of the previous issue, Cable has taken it
upon himself to solve Rumekistan's problems and within the first
5 pages of #29, he would appear to have done so in record time.
Qualms amongst the country's existing security forces & the
resistance movement are settled as the books remaining
protagonists are left to ponder the implications of Nate's
intervention. It really is rather good stuff. While I've been
willing to criticize the book in the past for its assocation with
a myriad of assorted cross-overs & plotlines, Fabian's plans for
Cable have remained on-track, despite the steady stream of
apparent interruptions. Issue #29 does its job in cementing
Cable's power-base, thus furthering Nate's agenda, but while the
issue, may seem like a standard conclusion to a solid two-parter,
it exposes something of a fissure in the Askani son's facade of
invulnerability & cool indifference. The results of which are a
reflection of a side of Nathan that had gone AWOL for quite some
time. Ask yourself, when was the last time you saw SPOILERS!
Cable cry?

This is the type of story that I've been clamouring for. Nicieza
avoids the easy option of dumping another character on Cable's
coat-tales. He takes a player from Nate's past, knowing full-well
the mastery which she has over him and through both her action &
inaction, succeeds in putting Nate through the emotional wringer.
The potency of whatever threat that Deadpool, Captain America or
S.H.I.E.L.D represented, pales in comparison to the significance
of Domino's influence here as we're left to sympathise with our
once so uncompromising lead. It's thought provoking yet saddening
and in all honesty, it couldn't have been played-out any better.

Wade on the other hand is up to his usual tricks. While it's
quite possible to bemoan his current position of lackey, the
current circumstances surrounding Cable's plight allow for the
ever-humorous Deadpool to be as reliable (in the humour stakes)
as they come. His interaction with Citizen V throughout is an
unabashed highlight, as is his participation in the issues final
scenes.

There's not really that much else to say about the issue. The
artwork is a step-above last issue's somewhat scratchier efforts
as Mark Brooks provides a cracking cover while Ron Lim comes
through with some adequate interiors, but while the artwork
serves its purpose, it's the plot and character interaction that
deserves all the credit here as the story quite simply outshines
the scribblings. In saying that, we've been quite lucky to
receive some preview art from the upcoming Civil War issues and
while Millar's registration act is over-riding all existing
storylines, the quality on display here, suggests that in this
instance, the artwork won't be overshadowed.

Well there you go. Without doubt, the finest issue of Cable &
Deadpool in quite some time. Allegiances are put into question,
the fourth-wall dupes its own advocate & Fabian illustrates that
frailty can be found in the most unlikely of people, at the most
unlikely of times.

OVERALL: 4.5

CIVIL WAR #2
Reviewer: Jason Grasso, Desperad07@aol.com

Any questions?

Writer: Mark Millar
Penciler: Steve McNiven
Inker: Dexter Vines
Colorist: Morry Hollowell
Letterer: Chris Eliopoulos
Assistant Editors: Molly Lazer & Aubrey Sitterson
Associate Editor: Andy Schmidt
Editor: Tom Brevoort
Editor In Chief: Joe Quesada
Publisher: Dan Buckley
Published By: Marvel Comics

WARNING: THIS REVIEW CONTAINS MAJOR SPOILERS.

If up until now, you've escaped the major spoiler that ends this
issue, I applaud you. However, given the fact that it's already
appeared in previews of Thunderbolts #103, the New York Post, AP
wire news, Howard Stern's radio show, and everywhere else, it's
in our best interest to follow suit, albeit with spoiler
etiquette firmly in place!

But first, let's start at the beginning. Civil War #2 starts with
S.H.I.E.L.D.'s search for the rogue Captain America. They find a
few villains and quickly realize that Cap isn't working alone and
the resistance is likely gaining strength. In fact, later on we
see that strength in the biggest action piece of the issue: a
rescue of the captured Young Avengers. Cap and Falcon, in a scene
seemingly under the direction of J.J. Abrams, disguised
themselves as S.H.I.E.L.D. agents and take over the rig carrying
the capture Young Avengers. Falcon is able to get Wiccan to
create a rather complex getaway bringing the team to one of Nick
Fury's S.H.I.E.L.D. safe houses. We learn that Fury is siding
with the resistance and will help in providing them all new
secret identities.

Meanwhile, at the Baxter Building, Reed Richards is busying
himself with a project while his wife shows signs of losing faith
in her husband and the registration act. Reed can't even disclose
the contents of a classified disc called "#42." This clearly sets
up Sue Richards as one of those who'll change sides, an
interesting dynamic for the Fantastic Four.

McNiven's art is really strong in this issue, going from intense
action sequencing to a few emotional close-ups. He starts off the
issue with a really great shot of the Vulture and the Grim
Reaper, both beaten bloody, tied to a pipe in the shadow-immersed
underground. McNiven also excels in the Young Avengers rescue
scene as well as the chase after Patriot. But it's not just the
broad action scenes that work.he captures some very complex
facial expressions here. Take a look at Tony Stark's look of
doubt while waiting in his penthouse.

Stark displays that very doubt because midnight is approaching
and with it the Registration Act will become law. (There isn't
any indication that he's been unveiled as Iron Man, despite this
happening in last week's Civil War: Frontline #1.) Later, he
leads a press conference about the new law and introduces Spider-
Man to help communicate the cause. But Spider-Man takes it a step
further and pulls his mask off. "My name is Peter Parker and I've
been Spider-Man since I was fifteen years old."

I had figured that Spider-Man's appearance at the conference was
just going to be to publicly side with the registration act. And
that Peter's conflict about appearing was in regards to a dilemma
about which side of the act he was really for. I really didn't
think Marvel would ever disclose the secret identity of one of
their icon characters. (In fact, Spider-Man has the advantage
that lots of super heroes don't have: his costume actually does
hide his entire face.)

Inevitably, the strongest response to this issue will be the
debate about the unmasking of Spider-Man. On one side there will
be traditionalists who feel it should remain a secret. On the
other side are the modernists who find secret identities to be
increasingly far-featched. Whose side are you on? At first, I
wasn't so sure I wanted to see one of the most treasured secret
identities in comicdom being revealed. There aren't many other
characters with as storied of a supporting cast as Peter Parker
and as great a dynamic that he had with those characters. But how
secret is his identity now? Almost all of his rogues gallery know
who he is, Aunt May knows, most of the good guys now know too.
There isn't a lot of intrigue when you're hiding your identity
from Jonah Jameson and a billion nobodies. This certainly opens
up the possibility for more interesting storylines for the
increasingly anti-climactic Spider-Man titles. It's not like Sins
Past and The Other did anything to change the status quo in
Peter's universe or least not anything we don't want to forget.
And there's only so much Tony Stark I can tolerate in Peter
Parker's life. This would be a great way to take the character
back to basics. (Any good Spidey fan would want to see how Flash
Thompson's reacts!)

My only issue is the limbo Daredevil seems to be in. In his title
proper, Matt Murdock is still in jail while an as-yet-unveiled
imposter has taken on the mantle of Daredevil. In Civil War, he's
playing vague background character. Brian Bendis spent years
crafting a story about Murdock's secret identity being revealed
and Murdock's quest to prove otherwise. Given his relationship
with Spider-Man, he would've made a great counterpoint to Peter's
choices. Unfortunately there haven't been any indications that
Daredevil will tie into Civil War at all, not made any easer by
the ill-timing of Murdocking being in jail.

Two issues in and Civil War already looks like a much more
promising 'event' than House of M. Whether or not this really
splits the Marvel Universe in the end remains to be seen so
there's still some time to botch this up. But if they can stick
to their guns, this event could truly deliver on the hype. And
give writers of other titles a cool new sandbox to play in. But
what's important is not just using the event as a means to an
end. Millar has crafted an incredibly interesting story and
helped shake up the status quo. House of M meandered, taking the
long, scenic route to "no more mutants." Here we're not only
interested in the greater ramifications of the Registration Act
but also the relationships and activities that are happening
because of the new law. Sure, some will cry "shock value" in
regards to Spidey's revelation but it never felt excessive in the
structure of the story. In fact, anything other than the
revelation would've betrayed the idealism behind those who
support the act.

OVERALL: 5.0
_________________________________________________________________






------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
Something is new at Yahoo! Groups.  Check out the enhanced email design.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/co.u8A/gOaOAA/Zx0JAA/bGIolB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~->

Thanks for subscribing to the Comic Book Network Electronic Magazine (CBEM)
--------------------------->Disclaimer<---------------------------
This is an ANNOUNCE only mailing list, only the Editor can send
messages to the list.  No one else has access to the subscriber list.
Replies to these messages will be received by the Editor ONLY,
so you must CC: individual contributors if you want them to get
your E-Mail.  The E-mail to the Emag MAY be used in future issues at
the Editor's discretion UNLESS you specifically request that they not
be.  It is our policy to withhold names and/or Addresses, by request only,
from letters of comment.  All contributors are required to use their real
name and have a valid Email address for their columns to be published.
Send Email comments to: ComicBkNet@aol.com

Material for inclusion in the Emag - press releases, solicitations,
column submissions, Letters to the Editor, guesses for the trivia
contest should be sent to ComicBkNet@aol.com

The EDITOR, not the submitter, has final approval and edit rights on
ALL material.  Printed comic books and advanced copies for review
in the Emag should be sent via US Mail or UPS to

David L. LeBlanc
84 Heather Circle
Jefferson, MA 01522-1419

TO Subscribe send a message FROM the intended address to:

        ComicBookNetworkEmag-subscribe@yahoogroups.com

TO Unsubscribe send a message FROM the address to be dropped to:

        ComicBookNetworkEmag-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

You may also unsubscribe from the Yahoo groups Web page at the short cut
below.
            Shortcut URL to the Yahoo group page:

        http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ComicBookNetworkEmag

All contents COPYRIGHT 2006 The Comic Book Network.
This message may be reproduced only in its original form, and in its
entirety, for non-commercial purposes.  Contact the original author(s)
or the Editor for permission to use individual items.

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ComicBookNetworkEmag/

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    ComicBookNetworkEmag-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/












<< June17, 2006 - [ComicBookNetwork E-Mag] CBEM 579.4 June17, 2006 - [ComicBookNetwork E-Mag] CBEM 579.8 >>
ComicBookNetworkEmag Archives Index | RSS
Google
 
Web http://archives.zinester.com
Archives powered by Zinester's Mailing List Service
Details on ComicBookNetworkEmag
Browse for more newsletters at Zinester's Ezine Directory
Managed by Zinester's Mailing List Management